UK Shortlists home UK Shortlists
Open primary navigation

Back to Storage & Backup

UK buying shortlist

Four First NAS Systems and Enclosures for Home Backup Worth Comparing (2026)

Compare three diskless two-bay NAS enclosures with one integrated 8TB personal-cloud appliance for a first home-backup system. The real decision is not just the box: include drive cost, usable capacity, setup, client support and an independent backup beyond the NAS.

Reviewed 02/08/2026 Key details checked How we chose Review details

Best starting point

Synology DiskStation DS223j (Diskless)

Check current price

Top 4 at a glance

Check a retailer or compare all four picks

Affiliate links may earn commission. Check current price, stock, delivery, returns and fit on the retailer page before buying.

The shortlist

Four options, with the trade-offs visible

Use the fit, limitations and checkout checks before opening a retailer page. Confirm the current price, stock, delivery and returns with the retailer.

Pick 1

First comparison point

Synology-compatible two-bay

Synology DiskStation DS223j (Diskless)

Verdict

Synology DS223j is the two-bay choice for buyers who need Synology's documented SHR, RAID 1 and current DSM/Btrfs support. It is a diskless enclosure. Trade-off: drives cost extra, memory is fixed at 1GB, networking is 1GbE and the bays are not hot-swappable. Check before buying: price compatible drives, calculate usable capacity, confirm every required app and choose an off-NAS backup destination.

Check lead pick on Amazon

Affiliate retailer link. Check current price, stock, delivery and returns before buying.

Highlights

  • Synology lists SHR and RAID 1 storage layouts for this two-bay enclosure.
  • Synology lists Btrfs support for DS223j on current DSM versions.

Drawbacks

  • It is diskless, limited to 1GbE and uses fixed 1GB memory.
  • Its bays are not hot-swappable, and mirrored disks do not replace a separate backup.

Buyer fit

Best for

  • Buyers who need a diskless two-bay Synology enclosure with documented SHR, RAID 1 and Btrfs support.

Not for you if

  • Buyers expecting included drives, hot-swap bays, faster networking or zero-administration backup.

Check before buying

  • Price compatible drives separately and calculate usable capacity for the chosen storage layout.
  • Confirm the 1GbE limit, non-hot-swap bays, app/client support and off-device backup destination.

Pick 2

2GB photo and snapshot apps

QNAP TS-233 (Diskless)

Verdict

QNAP TS-233 is the two-bay choice with 2GB fixed memory and documented photo-management, backup and snapshot apps. Trade-off: it is diskless, remains limited to 1GbE and creates ongoing app, account and security-update work. Check before buying: confirm the required QNAP apps, compatible drives, usable capacity and a separate backup target.

Check on Amazon

Affiliate retailer link. Check current price, stock, delivery and returns before buying.

Highlights

  • QNAP lists 2GB memory plus snapshot, photo-management and backup apps for this two-bay enclosure.
  • QNAP documents photo-management and backup applications for the platform.

Drawbacks

  • It is diskless, uses fixed memory and has only 1GbE networking.
  • Optional apps add setup, update and account-security responsibilities.

Buyer fit

Best for

  • Buyers who need a diskless two-bay enclosure with QNAP's documented photo-management, backup and snapshot apps.

Not for you if

  • Buyers seeking included storage, expandable memory, faster networking or a maintenance-free appliance.

Check before buying

  • Budget for compatible drives and calculate usable capacity before comparing enclosure totals.
  • Confirm the 1GbE limit, required apps, update routine, remote-access plan and separate backup target.

Pick 3

1GB Btrfs snapshot two-bay

ASUSTOR Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL (Diskless)

Verdict

ASUSTOR Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is the basic two-bay Btrfs/snapshot choice. Trade-off: it is diskless with fixed 1GB memory and 1GbE, so required apps and client support need closer checking than the hardware headline. Check before buying: price compatible drives, validate each client/app and design an off-device backup.

Check on Amazon

Affiliate retailer link. Check current price, stock, delivery and returns before buying.

Highlights

  • ASUSTOR documents two bays, Btrfs snapshot support and a three-year enclosure warranty.
  • It is included for those documented hardware and snapshot features, not as a speed or app-performance winner.

Drawbacks

  • It is diskless, fixed at 1GB memory and limited to 1GbE.
  • Check compatible drives and confirm that every required app supports the intended devices.

Buyer fit

Best for

  • Buyers who need a basic two-bay enclosure with documented Btrfs snapshot support and have checked the required ASUSTOR apps.

Not for you if

  • Buyers needing faster networking, memory expansion, included disks or zero setup.

Check before buying

  • Price compatible drives, calculate usable capacity and confirm the required ASUSTOR apps on every intended device.
  • Confirm the 1GbE/fixed-memory limits and off-device backup routine.

Pick 4

Integrated 8TB simplicity

Synology BeeStation Plus 8TB (BST170-8T)

Verdict

Synology BeeStation Plus 8TB is the simpler integrated-storage choice: the 8TB drive is included, so there is no drive-selection or installation step. Trade-off: it is a single-drive appliance, not a diskless two-bay enclosure, with no mirrored-disk layout or conventional NAS expansion path. Check before buying: confirm BST170-8T, supported apps and accounts, how files can be exported, and a separate USB or remote backup destination.

Check on Amazon

Affiliate retailer link. Check current price, stock, delivery and returns before buying.

Highlights

  • It is the only selected choice with integrated 8TB storage and no drive-installation decision.
  • It is included for integrated storage and fewer installation steps, not as a configurable RAID enclosure.

Drawbacks

  • It is a single-drive integrated appliance with no two-bay mirrored-disk option.
  • Its simplicity trades away drive selection, expansion and part of the control offered by a conventional NAS.

Buyer fit

Best for

  • Households that value integrated storage and fewer installation steps over a configurable two-bay enclosure.

Not for you if

  • Buyers who want replaceable multi-bay storage, RAID layout choice, broad NAS apps or a built-in second copy.

Check before buying

  • Confirm model BST170-8T, supported apps, account requirements, how files can be exported or recovered, and the USB backup method.
  • Budget an independent second destination because the appliance contains one internal storage drive.

Top 4 comparison

Compare the useful differences, trade-offs and final checks side by side.

Before you compare

Check these first

  1. 1List every phone and computer, then confirm a supported app or file-sharing method.
  2. 2For diskless systems, choose compatible drives and calculate usable capacity under the intended layout.
  3. 3Confirm the 1GbE network limit, setup/maintenance owner and account/security routine.

Your four roles

1Synology-compatible two-baySynology DiskStation DS223j (Diskless)Buyers who need a diskless two-bay Synology enclosure with documented SHR, RAID 1 and Btrfs support.

Trade-off:It is diskless, limited to 1GbE and uses fixed 1GB memory.

Not ideal for:Buyers expecting included drives, hot-swap bays, faster networking or zero-administration backup.

Check:Price compatible drives separately and calculate usable capacity for the chosen storage layout.

Check current price
22GB photo and snapshot appsQNAP TS-233 (Diskless)Buyers who need a diskless two-bay enclosure with QNAP's documented photo-management, backup and snapshot apps.

Trade-off:It is diskless, uses fixed memory and has only 1GbE networking.

Not ideal for:Buyers seeking included storage, expandable memory, faster networking or a maintenance-free appliance.

Check:Budget for compatible drives and calculate usable capacity before comparing enclosure totals.

Check retailer price
31GB Btrfs snapshot two-bayASUSTOR Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL (Diskless)Buyers who need a basic two-bay enclosure with documented Btrfs snapshot support and have checked the required ASUSTOR apps.

Trade-off:It is diskless, fixed at 1GB memory and limited to 1GbE.

Not ideal for:Buyers needing faster networking, memory expansion, included disks or zero setup.

Check:Price compatible drives, calculate usable capacity and confirm the required ASUSTOR apps on every intended device.

Check retailer price
4Integrated 8TB simplicitySynology BeeStation Plus 8TB (BST170-8T)Households that value integrated storage and fewer installation steps over a configurable two-bay enclosure.

Trade-off:It is a single-drive integrated appliance with no two-bay mirrored-disk option.

Not ideal for:Buyers who want replaceable multi-bay storage, RAID layout choice, broad NAS apps or a built-in second copy.

Check:Confirm model BST170-8T, supported apps, account requirements, how files can be exported or recovered, and the USB backup method.

Check retailer price

Choose this if / Avoid this if

Rule out poor-fit options before comparing finer details.

Avoid if

  • Avoid a NAS if nobody will own updates, account security, drive alerts, restore tests and off-device backup.
  • Avoid diskless enclosures if drive selection and installation are unacceptable; avoid BeeStation if replaceable multi-bay storage is required.

Dealbreakers

  • Do not buy a diskless enclosure until compatible drives and usable capacity are priced.
  • Pause if the required client/app, 1GbE limit, export method or independent backup destination is unclear.

Check before buying

  • List every phone and computer, then confirm a supported app or file-sharing method.
  • For diskless systems, choose compatible drives and calculate usable capacity under the intended layout.
  • Confirm the 1GbE network limit, setup/maintenance owner and account/security routine.
  • Choose and test an independent off-NAS backup destination.

Choose another shortlist if

  • Use an external hard drive if one computer needs a simpler local scheduled copy and network sharing adds no value.
  • Use a portable SSD if the job is fast transfer between a small number of devices.
  • Use the format guide if setup ownership and recovery architecture are still undecided.

When another role fits better

The first option is a useful starting point, not a universal winner. Move another role ahead when its use case, fit or ownership trade-offs match you better.

Known limitations

This structured desk review provides no independent measurements or first-party evidence for throughput, app quality, security, noise, power use, drive reliability, failover or restore success.

How we chose

The checks behind the four picks

We checked the named system or enclosure, whether drives are included, bays, memory, network limit, storage-layout options, support, warranty and matching UK listings. This desk review includes no independent measurements of speed, app quality, security, drive reliability or recovery.

  • Step 1: Complete system cost: Diskless enclosures require compatible drives; usable capacity, not raw drive total, is the comparable number.
  • Step 2: Apps and setup: Accounts, updates, permissions and restore steps determine whether the household can actually use the system.
  • Step 3: Network limit: All four selected systems use 1GbE networking; no faster-network outcome is implied.
  • Step 4: Recovery separation: RAID, SHR and snapshots can help with specific failures, but none replaces an independent backup.

Disclosure

Last reviewed: 02/08/2026

UK Shortlists may earn a commission when you use some retailer links. This does not increase the price you pay.

Retailers cannot pay to change which products we recommend or their order.

Prices, stock, delivery and returns can change. Confirm the final details with the retailer before buying.

Read more about how UK Shortlists makes money, retailer checks, and how corrections are handled.

Who checked this shortlist?

Written / compiled by:
UK Shortlists Editorial Team
Last reviewed:
02/08/2026
Review basis:
Key details checked

We compare published product information, retailer details and the buying criteria shown above. UK Shortlists does not currently publish claims based on first-party product use, laboratory testing or long-term testing.

FAQs & alternatives

Do these NAS products include drives?

DS223j, TS-233 and AS1102TL are diskless enclosures; buy compatible drives separately. BeeStation Plus BST170-8T includes one integrated 8TB drive and is not a two-bay enclosure.

Does RAID mean I have a backup?

No. Mirroring can keep a supported two-bay system running after one drive failure, but it does not protect against every deletion, compromise, device loss or site-level event. Keep an independent copy.

How should I compare cost?

For diskless systems add enclosure, compatible drives and any off-device backup cost, then compare usable capacity under the chosen layout. Do not compare enclosure price with an integrated 8TB appliance as if both include the same storage.

Also consider

  • Choose Integrated 8TB simplicity if drive selection and installation are bigger barriers than configuration flexibility.
  • Choose Synology-compatible two-bay if replaceable drives and Synology's documented SHR, RAID 1 and Btrfs support matter more.

Newsletter

Want the next useful buying check?

Get occasional UK Shortlists updates for decisions like this. Unsubscribe at any time.

Prefer the full details? Open newsletter page.

Related shortlists